Skip to main content
WeTalentia
Back to Insights
Legal1 min read

Understanding W2, 1099, and EOR: A Guide for European Employers

Three ways to pay someone in the United States, and the compliance consequences of choosing the wrong one.

European companies hiring their first US employee meet three acronyms in the first week. Each describes a legal relationship, not just a payroll method, and the choice determines tax exposure, benefits obligations, and the employee's own perception of the job.

W2: the employee

A W2 employee is on your US entity's payroll. You withhold income tax, pay employer payroll taxes, provide benefits above certain headcount thresholds, and carry workers' compensation and unemployment insurance. This is the standard for any permanent role, and it is the only structure WeTalentia places into.

1099: the independent contractor

A 1099 contractor invoices you and handles their own taxes. The structure is legitimate for genuinely independent work, and expensive when misused: a contractor who works fixed hours, uses your equipment, and reports to your manager is an employee in the eyes of the IRS and the Department of Labor, regardless of the contract. Misclassification penalties include back taxes, benefits, and in some states treble damages.

EOR: the employer of record

An employer of record hires the person onto its own US payroll and leases them to you. It is the fastest way to employ someone before your entity exists, and a reasonable bridge for the first six to twelve months. It is not a long-term home for a leadership team: the fees compound, the person's contract is with a third party, and equity or bonus plans become awkward.

A simple decision rule

  • Entity exists and the role is permanent: W2.
  • No entity yet and the role is urgent: EOR, with an entity plan.
  • Project-based, independent, outcome-defined work: 1099, with a lawyer's review.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Employment law varies by state; confirm your structure with US counsel before the first offer letter.

Written by

WeTalentia Editorial

Executive Search, Recruiting & HR Advisory

Building a team in North America?

Thirty minutes with us is usually enough to know whether a search makes sense. No obligation.

We typically respond within one business day.
See open positions

We represent European companies hiring across the US, Canada, and LATAM. All roles are confidential until the final interview stages.